Moran 2007

  • Dermot Moran, "Fink's Speculative Phenomenology: Between Construction and Transcendence," 2007.

Bruzina本の書評といって差し支えない内容。この本の重要性を評価しつつも、辛辣なコメントが随所で挿入される。たとえば、これ:

There is no doubt that Bruzina's book is an original work of phenomenology. It breaks new ground in its detailed understanding of Fink's development. But it is also the work of a true believer. Bruzina works with an implicit hermeneutical assumption that both Husserl and Fink were progressing intellectually to ever deepening insights. But sometimes we can go badly astray with that kind of assumption. It is also possible to hold that, after a late blooming in the years from 1929 to 1935, Husserl's thought went into decline and that many of his later ideas are quite daft to and that Fink was worse encourage him in that speculative direction. (p. 30)

概ね同意できる。